AW: [db-wg] Draft Minutes of the RIPE 52 DB-WG meeting
- Previous message (by thread): [db-wg] Draft Minutes of the RIPE 52 DB-WG meeting
- Next message (by thread): [db-wg] Draft Minutes of the RIPE 52 DB-WG meeting
Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ] [ subject ] [ author ]
Winfried Haug
wh at germany.com
Fri Apr 28 13:57:42 CEST 2006
Hello Rob, > > In the routing working group, Andrei presented a summary of the > discussion on the lists, but there was very little feedback from the > floor, or via Jabber, about which direction to move in. seems to me that the comments from the list were ignored. The problem we have is mentioned in rfc2725 section d 3 > > As I recall, Joao said he was going to write a summary of the points > to consider and put it out to the routing-wg list, where perhaps there > can be some more discussion. > > One of the reasons to approach this with caution is that the current > behaviour is as described in RPSS (RFC2725), and we'd like to get a > bit more feedback on why those authentication rules were chosen to > make a better decision on how to change them. Ok i looked at RFC2725: 9.1 "For example, when authorizing a route object software would look at "mnt-routes", if it does not exist, look at "mnt-lower", if that does not exist look at "mnt-by". " and more interesting: D.3 provider independent addresses and multiple origin AS Provider independent addresses and multihoming arrangement using multiple origin AS present a similar problem to multihoming. The maintainer of the address space and the maintainer of the AS is not the same. Permission can be granted using mnt-routes or multiple signatures can appear on the submission. Well the RFC is from 12/1999 , we have now 2006. Things may change!. Even 1999 people saw the problem and according to the wording in D.3 it is not clear that the mnt-routes must appear in the route object itself. It can also be seen that a mnt-routes in the inetobject itself could be used. Or am i wrong? Winfried --- Headlight Housing Factory | Rechenzentrum: Azenbergstrasse 35 | Neue Bruecke 8 D-70174 Stuttgart | D-70173 Stuttgart Fon: +49 711 2840 0 | e-mail: wh at headlight.de Fax: +49 711 2840 999 | http://www.headlight.de
- Previous message (by thread): [db-wg] Draft Minutes of the RIPE 52 DB-WG meeting
- Next message (by thread): [db-wg] Draft Minutes of the RIPE 52 DB-WG meeting
Messages sorted by: [ date ] [ thread ] [ subject ] [ author ]
[ db-wg Archives ]