[Apwg-ipv6-papi] [pdo] policy proposal done?

[Elvis Velea]

Hi everyone,

I managed to read the whole document and I want to thank Comms for their 
great work.

@Marco - I'd like to request three small changes, if that is still possible.

1. please update the e-mail address in the Authors section from 
elvis at velea.eu to elvis at v4escrow.net


2. I would like to add an other short rationale supporting the proposal:

Currently, organisations that want to offer services (other than shared) 
to their customers over IPv6 can only to this if they become an LIR. 
Non-LIRs can use IPv6 PI only to number their internal network and offer 
shared hosted services. This policy allows Non-LIRs to offer all of 
their services to customers over IPv6 as well.

(I had my coffee before writing this paragraph but I don't like how it's 
written, maybe you can reword it and make it shorter and clearer :)


3. I would split 6.1 in two different sections

6.1 Allocations for Anycasting TLD and
6.2 Allocations for Tier 0/1 ENUM Nameservers

(what do you think? would it be better to split it or just leave it as 
it is right now?)


the rest looks great.

thanks,
elvis

On 9/5/13 3:44 PM, Daniel Stolpe wrote:
>
> Thanks.
>
> I like the side-by-side layout.
>
> I will have another reading and see if something new pops up in the last
> minute.
>
> On Thu, 5 Sep 2013, Marco Schmidt wrote:
>
>> Dear proposers,
>>
>> please find attached the Comms-edited version of your proposal.
>>
>> Please take your time and check if everything is fine with you (title,
>> summary, rationale and policy text).
>>
>> I raised already the ticket with our webmasters to prepare the websites, but
>> we still can implement all possible changes that you might suggest until
>> Monday.
>>
>>
>> For a better overview I plan to present the current and new policy text
>> beside each other
>> (similar like for 2013-03
>> https://www.ripe.net/ripe/docs/other-documents/ipv4-address-allocation-and-assignment-policies-for-the-ripe-ncc-service-region-current)
>>
>> Do you like this idea or do you maybe have another idea?
>>
>>
>> Kind regards,
>> Marco Schmidt
>>
>>
>> On 9/2/13 5:49 PM, Elvis Velea wrote:
>>>   Hi Marco,
>>>
>>>   one day extra does not matter that much.
>>>
>>>   I still think we can wait until Comms has edited the policy proposal :)
>>>
>>>   Please ask them to go ahead and we will review the final document on
>>>   Thursday evening.
>>>   If all is ok, we can give the go-ahead for the webmaster to publish it on
>>>   the website and you can send the official announcement on Monday or
>>>   Tuesday :)
>>>
>>>   thanks for all the great work.
>>>
>>>   cheers,
>>>   elvis
>>>
>>>   PS: please ask them to update the e-mail address on the document from
>>>   elvis at velea.eu to elvis at v4escrow.net.
>>>
>>>   On 9/2/13 5:28 PM, Marco Schmidt wrote:
>>>>   Hello,
>>>>
>>>>   please find attached your policy proposal after the error check.
>>>>
>>>>   There is a little adjustment with Comms time estimation for the full
>>>>   edit - it's now estimated to be done until Thursday noon this week. I
>>>>   still expect the announcement will be possible next week Monday, latest
>>>>   Tuesday.
>>>>
>>>>   Please let me know if you would not like the full edit anymore.
>>>>
>>>>   Kind regards,
>>>>   Marco Schmidt
>>>>
>>>>
>>>>   On 9/2/13 12:00 PM, Gert Doering wrote:
>>>>>   Hi,
>>>>>
>>>>>   On Mon, Sep 02, 2013 at 11:26:51AM +0200, Elvis Velea wrote:
>>>>>>   @Gert & Sander, do you think this meets the schedule to have the
>>>>>>   discussion phase last until the end of October?
>>>>>   AFAIR, there's only a minimum time for discussion, so when we publish
>>>>>   next week, that would give us 7 weeks -> fine.
>>>>>
>>>>>   I'll be on vacation then, but Sander and Marco will handle all :-)
>>>>>
>>>>>   Gert Doering
>>>>>            -- NetMaster
>>>>
>>>
>>
>>
>
> Best Regards,
>
> Daniel Stolpe
>
> _________________________________________________________________________________
> Daniel Stolpe           Tel:  08 - 688 11 81                   stolpe at resilans.se
> Resilans AB             Fax:  08 - 55 00 21 63            http://www.resilans.se/
> Box 13 054							      556741-1193
> 103 02 Stockholm
>
>
> _______________________________________________
> Apwg-ipv6-papi mailing list
> Apwg-ipv6-papi at ripe.net
> https://www.ripe.net/mailman/listinfo/apwg-ipv6-papi
>

-- 
Kind regards, Elvis Velea