[ripe-list] RIPE Accountability Task Force Update at RIPE 75

+1

Best regards / Mit freundlichen Grüßen
Tahar Schaa
Management Consultant
 
Cassini Consulting GmbH
Bennigsen-Platz 1
40474 Düsseldorf

T +49 (0) 151 11 44 38 75

mail tahar.schaa at cassini.de  
visit www.cassini.de

Think green - keep it on the screen!
 


-----Ursprüngliche Nachricht-----
Von: ripe-list [mailto:ripe-list-bounces at ripe.net] Im Auftrag von Daniel Karrenberg
Gesendet: Donnerstag, 19. Oktober 2017 12:46
An: 
Betreff: Re: [ripe-list] RIPE Accountability Task Force Update at RIPE 75



On 19/10/2017 12:21, Nigel Titley wrote:
> I'm generally against additional complication, especially where past 
> practice doesn't give cause to worry, but as I say it doesn't really 
> bother me.

For what the opinion of one of the initial architects of this is worth:

Complication and over-specification bothers me greatly. Nothing good has ever come of it. A lot of headaches and some real badness have. Any unnecessary formalism creates friction losses at the very least.

I encourage everyone proposing additional formalism to first state very clearly the concrete *need* for adding it and to provide examples of concrete instances where the absence of such formalism has caused problems. Speculative instances in the future only count if there is consensus that they are either very likely to occur or have catastrophic consequences. In the latter case additional scrutiny of whether the added formalism will actually prevent the catastrophe is required.
Repeat: state a *need* not a desire or other lesser reason.

Daniel
speaking as co-founder of RIPE, initial architect of the RIPE NCC association, steady contributor to both and *not* speaking as a RIPE NCC employee