[atlas] Duplicate packet detection in traceroute results

Thank you for the code link, very useful!

I think this answers my question, and it's also as Jen described.

For reference, the traceroute bit I was trying to decypher is below...it 
looks like the router at hop 3 replies to the traceroute packet, but at 
the same time forwards it to the next router along the path, which also 
replies (the duplicates in hop 3's response have the source address of 
hop 4) - i guess this behaviour is very similar to the 'loops' described 
in the Paris traceroute paper 
(https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/1177080.1177100):

{   'hop': 3,
                       'result': [   {   'from': '2a02:2858:500:8::1',
                                         'rtt': 0.78,
                                         'size': 96,
                                         'ttl': 63},
                                     {   'dup': True,
                                         'from': '2a02:2858:500:3305::2',
                                         'rtt': 4.366,
                                         'size': 96,
                                         'ttl': 62},
                                     {   'from': '2a02:2858:500:8::1',
                                         'rtt': 0.786,
                                         'size': 96,
                                         'ttl': 63},
                                     {   'dup': True,
                                         'from': '2a02:2858:500:3305::2',
                                         'rtt': 4.347,
                                         'size': 96,
                                         'ttl': 62},
                                     {   'from': '2a02:2858:500:8::1',
                                         'rtt': 0.76,
                                         'size': 96,
                                         'ttl': 63},
                                     {   'dup': True,
                                         'from': '2a02:2858:500:3305::2',
                                         'rtt': 4.351,
                                         'size': 96,
                                         'ttl': 62}]},
                   {   'hop': 4,
                       'result': [   {   'from': '2a02:2858:500:3305::2',
                                         'rtt': 4.826,
                                         'size': 96,
                                         'ttl': 62},
                                     {   'from': '2a02:2858:500:3305::2',
                                         'rtt': 5.127,
                                         'size': 96,
                                         'ttl': 62},
                                     {   'from': '2a02:2858:500:3305::2',
                                         'rtt': 4.895,
                                         'size': 96,
                                         'ttl': 62}]},


Thank everyone for the responses!

Ana


On 20/01/2023 10:47, Michel Stam wrote:
> Hello Ana,
>
> I took a very quick look in the traceroute code, see here:
> ripe-atlas-probe-measurements.png
> ripe-atlas-probe-measurements/traceroute.c at 
> 7c03fba082e93b7a1f0f14cc3769bb31e83909e3 · 
> RIPE-NCC/ripe-atlas-probe-measurements 
> <https://github.com/RIPE-NCC/ripe-atlas-probe-measurements/blob/7c03fba082e93b7a1f0f14cc3769bb31e83909e3/eperd/traceroute.c>
> github.com 
> <https://github.com/RIPE-NCC/ripe-atlas-probe-measurements/blob/7c03fba082e93b7a1f0f14cc3769bb31e83909e3/eperd/traceroute.c>
>
> <https://github.com/RIPE-NCC/ripe-atlas-probe-measurements/blob/7c03fba082e93b7a1f0f14cc3769bb31e83909e3/eperd/traceroute.c>
>
> It seems that a sequence number in the traceroute packet is used. If 
> this sequence number is received back it’s marked as ‘response 
> received’. If another response is received within a certain timeframe, 
> it’s tagged as a duplicate. Otherwise its a late packet.
>
> Hope it helps.
>
> Cheers,
>
> Michel
>
>> On 20 Jan 2023, at 11:38, Ana Custura <ana at erg.abdn.ac.uk> wrote:
>>
>> Hi everyone,
>>
>> Just a question on how Atlas detects duplicate ('dup') packets in a 
>> traceroute.
>>
>> Is the 'dup' field added to a result when two received packets are 
>> exactly the same, regardless of whether they were received for a 
>> different initial TTL?
>>
>> Or are any packets that were unexpectedly received for a specific TTL 
>> marked as duplicates (e.g. if you receive 6 replies from 2 different 
>> IP addresses to the 3 initial packets sent with TTL 1, will 3 of 
>> these replies be marked as duplicates)?
>>
>> Thanks for your help!
>>
>> Regards,
>> Ana
>> -- 
>> ripe-atlas mailing list
>> ripe-atlas at ripe.net
>> https://lists.ripe.net/mailman/listinfo/ripe-atlas
>
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.ripe.net/ripe/mail/archives/ripe-atlas/attachments/20230120/d07fb9e9/attachment-0001.html>
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: ripe-atlas-probe-measurements.png
Type: image/png
Size: 100166 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <https://lists.ripe.net/ripe/mail/archives/ripe-atlas/attachments/20230120/d07fb9e9/attachment-0001.png>