[ncc-services-wg] Dear Olga Syra and Paul BD, thank you for your correspondence and position, but I would like to start a discussion not about personalities, but about proposals, the transfer of IP addresses from Ukraine.

Thank you, Ms. Olga, for your answer.

If you read my answer, please note that I wrote absolutely nothing about actions.
My proposal was precisely in the direction that RIPE NCC should develop the policies itself, and until such time as it does not have them, block transfers of IP addresses from the territory of Ukraine.

There were letters from the public that expressed a slightly different position, which I wrote about.
https://www.ripe.net/ripe/mail/archives/ncc-services-wg/2022-November/003654.html
I also believe that the current transfer procedure is imperfect and carries risks with regard to Ukraine's information security.

That is why we really need to discuss this issue.

Paul BD, thanks for your replies, but any suggestions?
I don't have the resources, but I believe that there are risks in transferring IP addresses, especially in occupied territories.

So, yes, new policies need to be developed to protect those LIRs that are delegated the use of IP addresses.

I also see risks regarding state information resources that are based on and use IP addresses that, for example, belong to IP addresses that are not under the jurisdiction of Ukraine.

I am confident that the RIPE NCC working group should look into these issues and make recommendations

  Paul BD, tell me who exactly I called and threatened? :)
If we are talking about the text of Mr. Tulev, then he is fooling the society, and instead of being constructive, he continues to accuse that someone is threatening him. Maxim fled the country, so nobody is interested in his active life.

Considering you are unconstructive, thanks for the chat, and goodbye.

I don't know who your lawyer is, but he is right, give him congratulations.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.ripe.net/ripe/mail/archives/ncc-services-wg/attachments/20221102/d4bd8571/attachment-0001.html>