[members-discuss] Re: New RIPE NCC Charging Scheme Models: Feedback Required

furthermore, considering the fact that ripes makes more probems about PI 
space than giving the END USER a LIR with (even more!) address space than 
requested in the PI :P

we are considering to use PA space -AS- PI space, and simply not announce 
it ourselves and give the end users a 100 year usage contract :P

there is nothing that says you have to announce PA space on your own 
network anyway.

-- 
Greetings,

Sven Olaf Kamphuis,
CB3ROB Ltd. & Co. KG
=========================================================================
Address: Koloniestrasse 34         VAT Tax ID:      DE267268209
          D-13359                   Registration:    HRA 42834 B
          BERLIN                    Phone:           +31/(0)87-8747479
          Germany                   GSM:             +49/(0)152-26410799
RIPE:    CBSK1-RIPE                e-Mail:          sven at cb3rob.net
=========================================================================
<penpen> C3P0, der elektrische Westerwelle
http://www.facebook.com/cb3rob
=========================================================================

Confidential: Please be advised that the information contained in this
email message, including all attached documents or files, is privileged
and confidential and is intended only for the use of the individual or
individuals addressed. Any other use, dissemination, distribution or
copying of this communication is strictly prohibited.


On Tue, 2 Aug 2011, Daniel Suchy wrote:

> On 08/02/2011 02:52 PM, Sven Olaf Kamphuis wrote:
>> On Mon, 1 Aug 2011, Daniel Suchy wrote:
>>> (and
>>> there're some organisations/LIRs activelly selling PI address space as
>>> their "service", charging much more [more than double] than they pay for
>>> the resource in RIPE).
>>
>> THIS my friend, is EXACTLY what a LIR is supposed to do. register ip
>> space for third parties and charge them for the service.
>>
>> the whole LIR == ISP crap, is a misinterpretation of the tasks of both
>> RIPE and LIRS, as is the fact that they encourage potential LIR
>> customers of becoming a LIR themselves, rather than paying a LIR to
>> register PI space for them (the legal aspects of which, are questionable
>> as well, after all, LIRS pay RIPE to enable them to register PI space,
>> not for RIPE to steal their customers ;)
>>
>
> Yes, LIR register addresses for their customers and charges them. That's
> clear.
>
> But, one of goals of LIR system (and internet registry system in
> general) is address space aggregation. And by the (resselled) PI space,
> this goal isn't reached at all - with PI, there's no aggregation. This
> is very often forgotten by some LIRs.
>
> "PI for everyone" is also one misinterpretation of LIR tasks. End users
> should be aware about the fact, that ISP(LIR) change does mean
> renumbering of their network and PI isn't here just because someone End
> users doesn't like this annoying job. LIR should learn about this their
> End users - but many LIRs doesn't do this part of their job.
>
> - Daniel
>
> ----
> If you don't want to receive mails from the RIPE NCC Members Discuss list, please log in to your LIR Portal account at: http://lirportal.ripe.net/
> First click on General and then click on Edit.
> At the bottom of the page you can add or remove addresses.
>