[iot-wg] another heave on the co-chair selection procedure

Hi Jim,

I also don't feel that consensus is the best available option for selecting people for positions. What could be used is anonymous voting ballots. I don't know what exactly software or platforms are used for that, but this is how we vote during elections at ICANN constituencies for example. And then the person is elected by the majority of votes. I believe it's better than consensus. With all the rest points I'm fine.

Best,
Olga



9 октября 2018, 18:45:12, от "Nigel Titley" <nigel at titley.com>:

On 09/10/18 16:29, Peter Koch wrote:
> On Tue, Oct 09, 2018 at 03:27:52PM +0100, Jim Reid wrote:
> 
>> (1) The IoT WG will have 2 co-chairs who serve staggered 2-year terms.
>> (2) A co-chair cannot serve more than 3 consecutive terms.
>> (3) Each year, the longest serving co-chair will stand down and subject to (2) may make themselves available for re-appointment.
>> (4) The incoming co-chair will be chosen by the WG using consensus and the remaining co-chair will make the consensus determination.
>> (5) Any circumstances not covered by the above will be resolved by the RIPE Chair whose  decision will be final.
> 
> I do not especially like it, because other WGs have demonstrated that a consensus process
> for personnel decisions easily degenerates.  However, I can live with that.
> 
> For item (3) I think what is meant is that the alternate terms are maintained,
> not that the "longest serving co-chair" will have to repeatedly ask for reappointment.
> "The co-chair whose term is up" would sound better to my ears, at least.

I hate to say this but Peter does have a point. We all understand what
you mean but one of these days a nit-picking bike shedder will come
along and we'll have to fix it. Peter's suggestion is sound, I think.

You can tell it's a quiet day.

Nigel

_______________________________________________
iot-wg mailing list
iot-wg at ripe.net
https://lists.ripe.net/mailman/listinfo/iot-wg
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <https://lists.ripe.net/ripe/mail/archives/iot-wg/attachments/20181012/0a00806f/attachment.html>