[dns-wg] DNS WG action item list update

Dear DNS WG,

during the preparation of the upcoming meeting it was noted that
the maintenance of our action item list at

	<http://www.ripe.net/ripe/wg/dns/actions>

has fallen behind a bit.  This message attempts to clean up the list
and resolve any ambiguity. Please do not hesitate to contact the
WG co-chairs if you have any questions or concerns.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

During RIPE 58, we addressed 57.1 "DLV for NCC maintained TAs" during the
RIPE NCC report:

        Anand talked first about AP 57.1: The RIPE NCC supports signing of the
        root and had planned to upload its trust anchors into the ISC DLV.

        He noted that somehow, this has happened without RIPE NCC knowledge.
        Contact has been made with ISC to investigate how this came about.

Further on:

        ACTION POINT: Anand to document the overhaul of provisioning methods to
        submit the Trust Anchors of zones signed by the RIPE NCC into ISC DLV.
        The draft solution to be distributed to the DB WG.

This became 58.1 with only being slightly different from 57.1.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

The summary from RIPE 58 reads:

	ACTION 58.1: NCC's KSKs in DLV
	 RIPE NCC to followup on the inclusion of RIPE NCC's TAs into ISC DLV

	ACTION 58.2: IN-ADDR.ARPA objects in the database
         Child objects for reverse zones in the RIPE DB were causing confusion
	 when a parent object was also present.  Since the parent zone was
	 already provisioned the child zone would have no effect.

	ACTION 58.3: RIPE NCC to evaluate feedback on Lameness Delegation checking
	 and incorporate this into any future work. Report back at RIPE 59.

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

The minutes for RIPE 59
	<http://www.ripe.net/ripe/groups/wg/dns/minutes/ripe-59>
say:

        58.2 IN-ADDR.ARPA objects in the database

        This has created an action item for the database WG.

        58.3 Feedback on lame delegations
        Research into the lame delegation project will be presented by Shane
        Kerr (ISC) later in the agenda.

Finally, the RIPE 59 minutes say:

        Peter proposed to keep action item 58.2 open so that the RIPE NCC can
        take care of this. He recommended closing NCC's KSKs and DLV action items
        (57.1 and 58.1).  There were no objections.

and later:

        Shane said he'd be happy to continue discussion on the mailing list.
	Peter proposed to close this action item (58.3).
	The WG agreed with this proposal.

The issue of parent/child domain objects in the database for the reverse tree(s)
was reported done by the DB group in a mail sent 09 Dec 2010:
<http://www.ripe.net/ripe/maillists/archives/dns-wg/2010/msg00113.html>

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Summary:

	We are going to list new action items 58.1, 58.2, and 58.3 as
	described above.  All of these plus 57.1 can be marked "done"
	as per the minutes of RIPE 59 and subsequent email from the NCC's
	DB group.

	No Action Items from RIPE 59, Lisbon, October 2009
	No Action Items from RIPE 60, Prague, May 2010
	No Action Items from RIPE 61, Rome, November 2010

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

Best regards,
   Peter
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: not available
Type: application/pgp-signature
Size: 186 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <https://lists.ripe.net/ripe/mail/archives/dns-wg/attachments/20110419/78415343/attachment.sig>