Re: [ncc-services-wg] Re: dnsmon / .org

[Daniel Karrenberg <]

[pruned to ncc-services]

On 10.09 05:00, Randy Bush wrote:
> > RIPE NCC should only monitor those ccTLDs that are LIRs or that
> > their LIR is willing to endorse.
> 
> as a lot of folk, whose primary mission it is, monitor, it is not
> clear to me why the ncc monitors at all.  

Frankly: Because root zone  data is needed for our operations,
none of the people whose primary mission it is do an adaequate job,
there is considerable interest in good measurements in the community
including about other TLDs and it was relatively easy to do.

> the philosphy that the
> ncc should provide all the services that we use devolves into ncc
> making shoes and shirts for us all too...

I am not aware of that school. can you point me to it?

Daniel