AW: [enum-wg] COCOM & ENUM ...

["Stastny Richard" <]

>For example some of our ISP (and acting as ".pl" Registrars too) are
>interested in ENUM domains registration (for VoIP services) but they MUST go
>through TSPs. And telcos are not interested to start ENUM domains
>registration... (they are also slowing down the NP implementation, so nobody
>expects special interest in ENUM).

Ha! This was exactly the reason why ETSI decided two years ago in
ETSI TS 102 051 "ENUM Administration in Europe" that there should
be an alternative way to get ENUM delegations if your TSP will not
do it. The possibility to port your number to a TSP providing ENUM
was NOT considered a proper alternative.

One does not need to be a fortune teller to anticipate this problem ;-)

-richard


________________________________

Von: Andrzej Bartosiewicz [
	    
	    
]
Gesendet: Mo 13.12.2004 10:53
An: Richard Shockey
Cc: Conroy, Lawrence (SMTP); Jim Reid; Stastny Richard; Carsten Schiefner; enum-wg@localhost
Betreff: Re: [enum-wg] COCOM & ENUM ...



Richard,

> This IMHO will cause Poland a problem over time as ISP who want to sell
> advanced services then realize they have to go through the incumbent to get
> registrations processed. But this is as we all know is a national matter
> and seeing how Poland deals with this will be very interesting to watch.

Are you a fortune-teller? We already have this problem!
For example some of our ISP (and acting as ".pl" Registrars too) are
interested in ENUM domains registration (for VoIP services) but they MUST go
through TSPs. And telcos are not interested to start ENUM domains
registration... (they are also slowing down the NP implementation, so nobody
expects special interest in ENUM).

> Authentication is not hard if your country has independent databases that
> can confirm the number holder. North America will not have that problem.

We do not have the independent database in Poland.

> Or they could use existing LNP databases ... ( ok that sounds really self
> serving )
>
> Note here 70% of US consumers who switch to Cable Based VoIP telephony
> actually port their primary number.

In Poland we have NP only in the Law (since July 2004), not in operation :(

Andrzej.