Re: [dns-wg] .ORG DNSSEC Survey

[bmanning@localhost]

>On Wed, Jun 25, 2008 at 03:28:09PM -0400, Edward Lewis wrote:
>> At 19:53 -0700 6/24/08, David Conrad wrote:
>> ...polled -some- root server operators..

	Emphasis mine
> 
> If indeed the (ICANN) root server operators have misgiving about the 
> experiment, could someone operating a root server express the reasons?
> 

	two things here.  DRC didn't not poll -all- the 
	operators, only some subset that he selected.

	re misgivings about sanctioned alternate roots that
	remain persistant... discusssions go back atleast a
	decade - details in old rssac minutes.

	in this case, (one) of the concerns is the defacto 
	hijacking of the root zone editorial function - which
	is still done under contract/MOU wiht DoC and VSGN.

	Just one POV.

--bill