Re: [db-wg] RIPE DB question

[Dmitry Kiselev <]

-----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE-----
Hash: SHA1

Hi!

On Thu, Aug 04, 2005 at 12:51:29PM +0400, Max Tulyev wrote:

> > Can I delete aut-num object from RIPE DB if it registered by me
> > (as LIR) for one of our customers and I have NO auth info refered by
> > object's mnt-by field?
> 
> I think you can't.

I think too. RIPE-252, part 3.6.2 says:

Only those mntners referenced by the "mnt-by:" attributes are authorised
to modify or delete the object.

For future delete I must keep my own mntner in all mnt-by fields for
customer's objects.  For inetnum it is not a big problem, its
modification rarely needed (mnt-routes helps also). Completely
different situation with aut-num object. Import/export fields are
subject of frequent change and each customer want to do it by himself
according to his routing policy. But he can't while LIR's mntner
protect an ASN object.

In other way, according to current IPv4 and ASN policies my
customer can use resources while "original criteria are still valid".
Neither LIR nor RIPE NCC can't free those resources.

Any additional agreement between LIR and customer are subject
of their country jurisdiction not RIPE. Even if there a contract
with words "must return recources if gone" RIPE can't do anything
with objects.

> So if you need to keep control on objects - keep your mnt-by there.

In this case customer must ask LIR to do any changes in RIPE DB.
It is not a best choise, I think.

- -- 
Dmitry Kiselev
-----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE-----

iD8DBQFC8fENZaocAwQhSAQRAiX0AJ94AzEa54WauVFyBwASPBzuOMM3vQCdH7r1
2LRuKKQBa7JbwVH2V/HxFEo=
=qYo1
-----END PGP SIGNATURE-----