Re: Who should do entries in RIPE database?

["Wilfried Woeber, UniVie/ACOnet" <]

>There is another problem too: some objects do have a mnt-by, however the
>mntner has auth: NONE! :(  Can we assume that these objects are well maintained?
>My answer is: no.

  I wouldn't follow that particular line of reasoning!

  The fact that you/he/she/someone does not *restrict access* to objects
  does not mean that the maintainer does not *maintain* the objects!?
  
  I think we're still mixing aspects of

  - access rights to objects (=access authorization)

  - access rights to "registry spaces" (=object creation)

  - authentication & identification (=credibility of data)

  and last but not least

  - object aging and checkpointing, 
    dangling pointers, non-ref.s, duplicates etc.

>Janos
>
>PS. I have seen this with both inetnum and route objects.

  Wilfried.