Re: Who should do entries in RIPE database?

[Carol Orange <]

Dear Carsten,

Yes indeed, the consistency problems in the RIPE database are well
known and are even well documented in:

ftp://ftp.ripe.net/ripe/dbase/info/consistency*

and

ftp://ftp.ripe.net/ripe/presentations/ripe-m26-orange-dbcons.ps.gz
or
http://www.ripe.net/meetings/ripe/ripe-26/pres/db-consist/

Our plans to deal with them are also documented in:

ftp://ftp.ripe.net/ripe/presentations/ripe-m27-orange-woeber-dbcons.ps.gz
or
http://www.ripe.net/meetings/ripe/ripe-27/pres/db/consistency/

We do plan to try to eliminate multiple objects pointing to the same
person, as well as other clean ups of the person data. [As a side
note, this project is now well underway.]

We have not however discussed limiting the ability to enter data in
the RIPE database, outside of the current and proposed authorization
mechanisms. That would certainly be a significant change of course,
and for that reason, I have cc'd the RIPE Database working group on
this mail to get their feedback on this idea.

Greetings,

Carol Orange
RIPE NCC
 
In message <3456024C.70C28953@localhost, 
Carsten Schiefner writes:

>> As a result of a voluminous discussion with one of POPs I would like to
>> point your interest on the following topic I am a little bit upset of:
>> 
>> Almost everybody who knows about about the RIPE database schema (which
>> is no secret at all!) can do entries just by sending a mail to
>> 'auto-dbm@localhost. This leads to an overwhelming bunch of multiple,
>> bad maintained or what-ever-you-want entries - especially person
>> objects - without any fun in grepping through them and selecting the
>> right one to create a new object. Example:
>> 
>> There are four(!) entries for the entity "Joerg Schmidt" of "ZWF
>> Digitale Informations Technologie GmbH": JS893-RIPE, JS1161-RIPE,
>> JS1163-RIPE and JS1438-RIPE. This should be definitely stopped!
>> 
>> My idea is that we should discuss future restrictions on the possibility 
>> for everybody to put entries in the RIPE database, maybe by setting up
>> and maintaing access lists for every LIR.
>> 
>> For me this database is a central tool in my daily work and I am very
>> interested in keeping quality and reliability of stored data as high
>> as possible.
>> 
>> Kind regards,
>> 
>> 	Carsten Schiefner
>> -- 
>> 
>> Carsten Schiefner                         
	    
	    

>> TCP/IP GmbH, Berlin (Germany) - Contrib.Net     http://www.contrib.com
>>      Phone: +49.30.44 33 66-0             Fax: +49.30.44 33 66-15
>> ======================================================================