[address-policy-wg] Re: [address-policy-wg] Re: [address-policy-wg] 2006-07 – Minimum IPv4 Assignment Window

[Sascha Lenz slz@localhost]

Hi,

leo vegoda schrieb:
> Hi,
>
> On Mon, Oct 23, 2006 at 05:00:11PM +0200, leo vegoda wrote:
> > Dear Colleagues,
> >
> > During the Address Policy WG session at RIPE 53, we were asked to
> > provide statistics showing
> >  - how many of the requests to make a PA assignment involve
> > discussion with the requester; and
> >  - how much discussion takes place in those requests.
> I hope people found these statistics useful and that they emphasise the 
> motivation for the proposal. If anyone has any questions, or if there is 
> a need for additional information, please let me know. I would also love 
> to see more discussion on this list before the end of the discussion 
> period on 29 November.
well i already commented on 2006-07 in <4523D145.6050506@localhost> and 
since the statistics didn't really change anything, i don't want to 
repeat myself here (in short: it was a vote in favor of the proposal, 
for those who count votes :-).
I only mentioned some concern about no slow-start mechanism at all, but 
basically a per-LIR AW doesn't make much sense anyways.
Usuallly "older", "bigger" LIRs have quite some "high" AW already, even 
if they have a high fluctuation of LIR-contacts/hostmasters, too 
(students ect.)
So, personally, the current AW doesn't tell that much about quality of 
Assignments made anyways - it's quite obsolete from this p.o.v.
So, if noone wants to discuss the possibility of a 
per-LIR-contact-personal-AW (which would be nice in job interviews - 
"hey, i have a /14 AW, i'm best, hire me!" :-), i'm still in favor of 
this request, it fits in the reality.
--
========================================================================
= Sascha Lenz                  SLZ-RIPE          slz@localhost         =
= Network Operations                                                   =
= BayCIX GmbH, Landshut                  * PGP public Key on demand *  =
========================================================================