Re: New Document available: RIPE-271
- Date: Fri, 09 May 2003 16:54:50 +0100
Here in HEAnet, we've been working with RIPE to perform the hostcount for
.ie since before there was a RIPE or a HEAnet:) From this point of view, we
have some comments on this new document.
Despite the title of document RIPE-271, the term 'hostcount' seems to be
used purely to provide an extended historic baseline for the statistical
work of RIPE NCC. The document is silent on proposals to improve the
quality of the hostcount and, thereby, the integrity of the DNS. There is
still a lot of useful information, for statisticians, planners, DNS
hostmasters and the general public, which is made available from the
analysis of the hostcount so it is a shame that the document concentrates
only on TTM and RIS.
Although it cannot be inferred that this is the intent, if the principles
of openness outlined for TTM were to be extended to the hostcount, it would
undermine previous assurances given by RIPE that the raw hostcount
information would not be generally available
In our experience, it is this assurance that has encouraged people to
permit zone transfers to the IE collector who otherwise would not have so
done. To remove it at this point would undermine the integrity of RIPE in
the eyes of those working under that assumption at the moment and even
fewer would be likely to facilitate the hostcount in the future.
Ann Harding Phone: +353-1-660-9040
HEAnet Ltd. Fax: +353-1-660-3666
Network Operations Centre Email: noc@localhost
At 02:34 PM 5/8/2003, you wrote:
New RIPE Document Announcement
A new document is available from the RIPE document store.
Title: RIPE NCC Hostcount in the 21st Century
Author: Daniel Karrenberg
Date: 8 May 2003
Format: PDF=98090 TXT=8008
Short content description
RIPE NCC Hostcount in the 21st Century
A New Direction for Measurements by the RIPE NCC
The RIPE NCC has collected data and published statistics
from its inception. In fact the hostcount has even started
before the RIPE NCC began operations. Other measurement and
data collection activities have been added later, most
notably Test Traffic Measurements (TTM) and the Routing
Information Service (RIS).
After more than 10 years it is time to re-visit this area
and adjust the direction based on input from the RIPE
community and the NCC membership. This memo proposes the
new direction and seeks to establish consensus among the
RIPE NCC membership.
Accessing the RIPE document store
You can access the RIPE documents in HTML format via our website at
the following URL:.
The RIPE Document Store is also available via anonymous FTP to
ftp.ripe.net, in the directory ripe/docs.
The URLs for the new documents on the FTP-server are:
ftp://ftp.ripe.net/ripe/docs/ripe-271.pdf PDF version
ftp://ftp.ripe.net/ripe/docs/ripe-271.txt plain text version