From richard at shockey.us Fri Feb 3 21:52:43 2006 From: richard at shockey.us (Richard Shockey) Date: Fri, 03 Feb 2006 15:52:43 -0500 Subject: [enum-wg] United States ENUM Trial Launches February 21 In-Reply-To: References: Message-ID: <43E3C29B.8040205@shockey.us> Press Release Source: Country Code 1 ENUM LLC US ENUM Trial Launches February 21 Friday February 3, 11:33 am ET Companies Interested in Participating in the Trial Should Plan on Attending This Meeting DENVER--(BUSINESS WIRE)--Feb. 3, 2006--The Country Code 1 ENUM LLC (LLC) today announced the formation of a committee to coordinate testing activities among participants in its upcoming US ENUM trial. The first meeting of this committee, to be known as the LLC's Trial Participants Advisory Committee (TPAC), will take place in Richardson, Texas, on February 21, 2006. Companies who have an interest in participating in the trial should plan on attending this meeting. Meeting details will be posted on the LLC's web site (http://enumllc.com). The US ENUM trial will be based on the ENUM Forum's "Framework Document for a US/CC1 ENUM Trials Program," which can be found at http://www.enumf.org/home. The U.S. trial is expected to be conducted over a six-month period beginning in March. Companies wishing to participate can fulfill one or more of the defined roles for the trial: Tier 1B Registry, Tier 2 Nameserver Provider, Registrar, Authorization Agency, Host Carrier, Application Service Provider, and User Registrant. Companies choosing to participate are responsible for their own costs and will be expected to sign a Memorandum of Understanding with the CC1 ENUM LLC, which will be available on the LLC's web site (http://enumllc.com). Several telecommunications and Internet companies have already indicated an interest in participating. ENUM is a technology that allows users to combine the resources of the Internet with traditional telephony, uniting these two diverse worlds of communications and enabling a whole new range of communication applications. The ENUM system effectively enables individuals, businesses and other organizations to maximize the use of both the public Internet and the Public Switched Telephone Network (PSTN) by associating telephone numbers with Internet domain names. As a result, phone numbers can be used to send traditional telephony services like voice calls or faxes which can be converted to packets for delivery to a variety of devices. On December 1, 2005, the U.S. government requested the temporary delegation of country code 1 to support an ENUM trial. That request was also supported in letters from the Canadian and Jamaican governments. Confirmation of the delegation is expected in mid-February, with the US ENUM trial expected to start in early March. During the next year, other NANP member countries may conduct national ENUM trials as well. The TPAC will coordinate the various trial activities and report the results of the trial to the LLC, which will publish the results and report them to various governmental agencies that have been following the industry's efforts toward ENUM implementation. The TPAC will be chaired by a Project Executive to be contracted for and selected by the LLC. Additional details and registration information for the meeting on February 21 will be posted on the LLC's web site. About Country Code 1 ENUM LLC The founding companies of Country Code 1 ENUM LLC are seeking to build a commercial implementation consistent with the relevant open standards of the Internet Engineering Task Force (IETF) and the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) upon which ENUM is based. The new company will help to implement a single, public ENUM system for those nations within the NANP that choose to participate. The North American implementation of ENUM will adhere to national and industry privacy requirements. Country Code 1 ENUM LLC will manage the public infrastructure that translates traditional telephone numbers into Internet domain names, combining the reach and capabilities of the Internet with the Public Switched Telephone Network (PSTN) to enable new communications capabilities. -- >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Richard Shockey, Director - Member of Technical Staff NeuStar Inc. 46000 Center Oak Plaza - Sterling, VA 20166 sip:rshockey(at)iptel.org sip:57141(at)fwd.pulver.com ENUM +87810-13313-31331 PSTN Office +1 571.434.5651 PSTN Mobile +1 703.593.2683 Fax: +1 815.333.1237 or ; <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< From enumvoipsip.cs at schiefner.de Sun Feb 5 16:26:27 2006 From: enumvoipsip.cs at schiefner.de (Carsten Schiefner) Date: Sun, 05 Feb 2006 16:26:27 +0100 Subject: [enum-wg] United States ENUM Trial Launches February 21 In-Reply-To: <43E3C29B.8040205@shockey.us> References: <43E3C29B.8040205@shockey.us> Message-ID: <43E61923.6030202@schiefner.de> Hi Rich, I am all excited about these news - I still wonder, however, if there isn't a crucial thing missing. Although the press release states: > On December 1, 2005, the U.S. government requested the temporary > delegation of country code 1 to support an ENUM trial. That request was > also supported in letters from the Canadian and Jamaican governments. > Confirmation of the delegation is expected in mid-February, [...] I haven't seen any request for a delegation of 1.e164.arpa coming yet via the RIPE NCC/ITU framework. Can you help us out here re. the status? Thanks - and have a nice weekend remainder, all: -C. From enumvoipsip.cs at schiefner.de Sun Feb 5 23:13:17 2006 From: enumvoipsip.cs at schiefner.de (Carsten Schiefner) Date: Sun, 05 Feb 2006 23:13:17 +0100 Subject: [enum-wg] United States ENUM Trial Launches February 21 In-Reply-To: <0IU800B21FJWZP@dgismtp06.mcilink.com> References: <0IU800B21FJWZP@dgismtp06.mcilink.com> Message-ID: <43E6787D.3060605@schiefner.de> Karen, Karen Mulberry wrote: > The request to delegate Country Code 1 was submitted to the ITU in mid > December 2005 by the United States, Canada and Jamaica. The request is > currently in the ITU 60 day administrative approval period for a shared > country code and I expect that the delegation approval from the ITU will > occur before the schedule February 21st US trial kick-off date. from what I know the request should also have been sent to the RIPE NCC's email address for that very purpose, . ITU's ad interim procedures: http://www.itu.int/ITU-T/inr/enum/procedures-02.html from my point of view are not really clear about the handling of an initial delegation request directly and _only_ sent to the ITU. However, they do speak about receiving such requests from the RIPE NCC which is in line with the instructions given to the RIPE NCC by IAB: http://iab.org/documents/docs/2004-08-12-enum-instructions.html Please find the RIPE NCC's How-To at: http://www.ripe.net/ripe/docs/enum-request.html This process is the one that AFAIK has been used for all other delegations so far. You may want to double-check. Best, Carsten From karen.mulberry at verizon.com Sun Feb 5 21:57:31 2006 From: karen.mulberry at verizon.com (Karen Mulberry) Date: Sun, 05 Feb 2006 13:57:31 -0700 Subject: [enum-wg] United States ENUM Trial Launches February 21 In-Reply-To: <43E61923.6030202@schiefner.de> Message-ID: <0IU800B21FJWZP@dgismtp06.mcilink.com> Carsten, The request to delegate Country Code 1 was submitted to the ITU in mid December 2005 by the United States, Canada and Jamaica. The request is currently in the ITU 60 day administrative approval period for a shared country code and I expect that the delegation approval from the ITU will occur before the schedule February 21st US trial kick-off date. Karen N. Mulberry Sr. Project Manager, Numbering Verizon PLEASE NOTE NEW EMAIL ADDRESS Email: karen.mulberry at verizon.com -----Original Message----- From: enum-wg-admin at ripe.net [mailto:enum-wg-admin at ripe.net] On Behalf Of Carsten Schiefner Sent: Sunday, February 05, 2006 8:26 AM To: Richard Shockey Cc: enum-wg at ripe.net Subject: Re: [enum-wg] United States ENUM Trial Launches February 21 Hi Rich, I am all excited about these news - I still wonder, however, if there isn't a crucial thing missing. Although the press release states: > On December 1, 2005, the U.S. government requested the temporary > delegation of country code 1 to support an ENUM trial. That request > was also supported in letters from the Canadian and Jamaican governments. > Confirmation of the delegation is expected in mid-February, [...] I haven't seen any request for a delegation of 1.e164.arpa coming yet via the RIPE NCC/ITU framework. Can you help us out here re. the status? Thanks - and have a nice weekend remainder, all: -C. From enumvoipsip.cs at schiefner.de Wed Feb 15 15:08:13 2006 From: enumvoipsip.cs at schiefner.de (Carsten Schiefner) Date: Wed, 15 Feb 2006 15:08:13 +0100 Subject: [enum-wg] Delegation of +1/1.e164.arpa (almost) completed Message-ID: <43F335CD.2040106@schiefner.de> Dear colleagues, the ENUM delegation request for 1.e164.arpa - +1 is the E.164 CC for the North American Numbering Plan (NANP) - has just been confirmed by ITU-T TSB. I expect the technical delegation to be just a matter of time then. Furthermore, given the size of possible delegations under 1.e164.arpa, I consider this a major step forward for Public User ENUM. Congratulations to all who worked on the ENUM LLC and on the project in general over the last couple of years. Best, Carsten Schiefner -------- Original Message -------- Subject: [enum-announce] Fw: NCC#2006021663 [RE: [Country Code 1 ENUM delegation request]] Date: Wed, 15 Feb 2006 14:39:34 +0100 From: RIPE NCC Staff Reply-To: RIPE NCC Staff To: enum-announce at ripe.net ----- Begin forwarded message ----- Date: Wed, 15 Feb 2006 14:19:13 +0100 From: To: Subject: RE: NCC#2006021663 [Country Code 1 ENUM delegation request] Message-Id: <334A4109C6BEA14ABB48EBCF274A6C8A0187C7E1 at MAILBOX1.blue.itu.ch> The TSB confirms that the attached request for ENUM delegation of code 1 has been authorized by the concerned national Administrations for the purposes of technical trials for a period ending no later than one year after the confirmation of the delegation by RIPE NCC. The delegation may proceed when RIPE NCC receives formal confirmation from the Director of TSB. Richard Hill ----------------------------------------- Richard Hill Counsellor, ITU-T SG2 International Telecommunication Union Place des Nations CH-1211 Geneva 20 Switzerland tel: +41 22 730 5887 FAX: +41 22 730 5853 Email: richard.hill at itu.int Study Group 2 email: tsbsg2 at itu.int > -----Original Message----- > From: RIPE NCC Staff [mailto:enum-request at ripe.net] > Sent: Wednesday, 15 February, 2006 10:36 > To: enum-announce at ripe.net; Hill, Richard > Subject: Fw: NCC#2006021663 [Country Code 1 ENUM delegation request] > > > ----- Begin forwarded message ----- > > Date: Tue, 14 Feb 2006 15:17:05 -0500 > From: Matt Pounsett > To: enum-request at ripe.net > Subject: NCC#2006021663 Country Code 1 ENUM delegation request > Message-Id: > > > -----BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE----- > Hash: SHA1 > > Domain Object > > domain: 1.e164.arpa. > descr: North American ENUM Mapping > admin-c: JB001-RIPE > tech-c: CIRA01-RIPE > zone-c: CIRA01-RIPE > nserver: ns01.enum-1a.ca > nserver: ns02.enum-1a.ca > mnt-by: MNT01-RIPE > mnt-lower: MNT01-RIPE > changed: matt.pounsett at cira.ca 20051101 > source: RIPE > > Admin Contact > > person: James Baskin > address: CC1 ENUM LLC > address: c/o McKenna Long and Aldridge LLP > address: 1875 Lawrence St, Suite 200 > address: Denver, CO 80202 > fax-no: +1 425 963 5445 > e-mail: baskin at enumllc.com > nic-hdl: JB01-RIPE > changed: matt.pounsett at cira.ca 20051101 > source: RIPE > > Zone/Tech Contact > > role: CIRA ENUM Registry > address: CIRA ENUM Registry > address: 350 Sparks Street, Suite 1110 > address: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada > address: K1R 7S8 > phone: +1 613 237 5335 > fax-no: +1 613 237 0534 > e-mail: admin-enum at cira.ca > nic-hdl: CIRA01-RIPE > admin-c: JP01-RIPE > tech-c: CIRA01-RIPE > mnt-by: MNT01-RIPE > changed: matt.pounsett at cira.ca 20051101 > source: RIPE > > Maintainer Object > > mntner: MNT01-RIPE > descr: CIRA ENUM Registry Operations > admin-c: JP01-RIPE > tech-c: CIRA01-RIPE > upd-to: admin-enum at cira.ca > mnt-nfy: admin-enum at cira.ca > auth: PGPKEY-F8DB0BCB > notify: admin-enum at cira.ca > mnt-by: MNT01-RIPE > changed: matt.pounsett at cira.ca 20051101 > source: RIPE > > Key-Cert Object > > key-cert: PGPKEY-F8DB0BCB > certif:-----BEGIN PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- > certif:Version: GnuPG v1.4.1 (Darwin) > certif: > certif:mQGiBD8lZWMRBADUV5YbtxUlWGJwvwF3fK7PjmcmylncnhV81g+QdqU > HQ5IczWW9 > certif:3bEQVdag2sIiVfWA9ouSFd16R/7PUsV9k/xloqEYQfKQd1FfNrkUL5D > FdM/9QFQ1 > certif:c09/BLL0utUwGLgPfyB7CNgDAFmiBrmAh73jlQQ4zDoCr1ZYv9w+eUt > YnwCg+vM2 > certif:tREDAs1fCPstGqxNeS754ZUEAIWLdiwLyN2PYazFsUKBb+x4p9RqgiS > Gja8ZED4u > certif:q9j/Ve3x1ZKdNWcOkhF4/hkSHjB9iA4pgq1YCH12B0BtZT3+hBgF2wt > qMsxHpJ+P > certif:58rYFqdmu6bbD//LAcdJ7555xxYcuaSRPetpcb2cGsdZjJ7VmOqpPF6 > 3tdPLTew8 > certif:/sriA/43UdHFzfXB4LzS+IisLqZLuXRXSydjkSBac8jTE8BAxXlgaNN > gZWT45cCF > certif:i6/wDdhD7l8S2RJB4xvdV3llTU5OpMeluhJRmFHJdAoCBCFipI5sveB > Tj9MgHOjv > certif:hqF7Z4zayPB/HP0LarW4UeB99xFIOAPV/sWZ9FBj5VNi1PrzdrQzTWF > 0dCBQb3Vu > certif:c2V0dCAoUGVyc29uYWwgRW1haWwpIDxtYXR0QGNvbnVuZHJ1bS5jb20 > +iF4EExEC > certif:AB4CGwMGCwkIBwMCAxUCAwMWAgECHgECF4AFAkIzpBkACgkQae4z2vj > bC8sj8ACe > certif:Jsvj5N3YJobxQmuq847q67I9nmEAoLfj2ZBbwdMgKMLI7toegl6YHdQ > atCVNYXR0 > certif:IFBvdW5zZXR0IDxtYXR0LnBvdW5zZXR0QGNpcmEuY2E+iF8EExECAB8 > CGwMECwcD > certif:AgMVAgMDFgIBAh4BAheAAhkBBQJAsQlAAAoJEGnuM9r42wvL1zkAn0Z > aKEOj9Y6n > certif:4R1MY5cSKXDNkDViAKCEVrHAXY0Z5lu7zpDpeJeuLc/hvIhGBBARAgA > GBQI/JWq0 > certif:AAoJEASBw5fnLV8w9F0An2gkid4k6BYhkqwF394WG/59GXKAAJ9NW62 > E8N1SX+BF > certif:YkHc36JiGhPFc4hGBBMRAgAGBQJAs43xAAoJEMOLmjAkEC21INEAmQF > urhg1Sl2S > certif:wX/ihD21rHGuFy4wAJ95zqH7TbeyBI5XxEHJrXofzsUwjohGBBIRAgA > GBQJAsRVU > certif:AAoJENIP1AXK1QnGT+4An26Ws1nDuvnb+HEx9TRA7m5OmB5xAJ9lRtj > mxkbJZ4Sm > certif:RbOOrU9QoFQhGYhGBBIRAgAGBQJAsRV7AAoJEP3/j1jk20TytpgAoLq > Z8G70ic4o > certif:bNNrVXuYKN4MTXQCAJ9xcNaj7ozcPDlpLlknA25R4aTU+4hGBBMRAgA > GBQJAs3aZ > certif:AAoJEHLrsbD/Cs/x8DcAnR5AWACCqbE1FAVwJiVUtVQB07B6AJ9cpaX > tgkZOG3EQ > certif:Ez8hvBnS6afmpIkAlQMFEECzyyMHTRtfOVdXPQEBsVED/3rcjWhBBPY > bprcMPEJP > certif:UGr4t06Mos+Mx2pTUrgptS7+mh5OlsZX96P4HXpNvFUoUTC7gq/wIs0 > MJ+R72oaJ > certif:1t9z1iV9kh6mBs8LOveICdn72ScU0GlS6pfJx+OCr+3HQdA/j0ZdJn4 > LsijE2zOe > certif:mklKjQ1+Xl0j5o6Ajq7ppW8GiEYEExECAAYFAkCy+FEACgkQROB/wlN > WTDZ3/wCg > certif:vTAaMihTvFCQgGHoaDzFjpSsesMAn1PryPCY9lWFlOsRieFUji63SFh > yiEYEExEC > certif:AAYFAkC03rMACgkQ2ZjBE2zZsp9l6gCffa4GoDOBhKLZiQB01aF8Kb/ > TUQ4An222 > certif:udONtJFQTz472oT29OPta57LiEYEExECAAYFAkC07ZcACgkQNh6mMG5 > yMTbCFgCf > certif:SkKdlQ6MqvuHoi46/ng5UkpACCQAn3OUZhP3oSrwWcSRE+FYH8GJnMv > 0iEYEEBEC > certif:AAYFAkCy5fsACgkQnFcIO/K8+cHdqACdF9jfFA8rYbeMT1IrsNI/Aoo > jc/AAoLVu > certif:J6rYAUgJymLmos+lUSa0d7m0iEYEEBECAAYFAkCzdswACgkQqFN4NA7 > /LWhNFQCb > certif:BA/486okoS2QOhy2o8SH45S5f7YAnAi4jE3K8I9dALBwkpn7M8VxqSh > WiEYEEhEC > certif:AAYFAkC48ugACgkQNnstYOXbLtrHpACfb0wHv2Rrjb2PXyfsBmgmddV > K9jQAn36N > certif:UunxQ9m1ybdOOhCeCNSyn/2QiEYEEBECAAYFAkCy2JIACgkQpqs0pdM > 8UJWRZgCf > certif:d72WXPmu1jGMBWFx9T5tdWfb08UAnRD4HV8ENY285jzhUBqG8Qrqcbc > diQEmBBAB > certif:AQAQBQJA8rqCCQZuYW5vZzMxAAAKCRDlsSGMn56vyxjbCACZ3XuEdU0 > UlZPnouIf > certif:3P8gPLfiEl+i3a1+cux9xAL8bsjfGX1Vy+hn33saCeuGZohMUv4RTbW > q5NaDGrth > certif:+IWiqZgWbsrAGDVlEXIGYItYV6Ug8+d1ORA1A8n6sZ5iDwVfSFfenPU > ktX/Nfdpe > certif:HSHaM//IPiAQPfz7QXr+JC1X7Gs0gGVNqWenePqyxxJA5KguoB+Ae/O > E1bjGvzxc > certif:gRF3OS6rHbCXGLtOyOgq9A7Xm1Ozvr1qwsRdXvdSAZlqgVqFaKOxsxr > TQtewvdzk > certif:28gRvQGdjsgHGviEaQAF30nsK4MFitIvKnaZbOgO5EETEppd7APhms1 > YOh7B5po6 > certif:gTSpiEYEEhECAAYFAkF1lVgACgkQXArMTfW646Na6ACgmhEEIjnjqhq > rE9kFanKR > certif:GVYVH9YAn2BeYF3wvrJKaIpmWD0sBfRP6zLGtCNNYXR0IFBvdW5zZXR > 0IDxtYXR0 > certif:cEBjb251bmRydW0uY29tPohcBBMRAgAcBQJAsQrQAhsDBAsHAwIDFQI > DAxYCAQIe > certif:AQIXgAAKCRBp7jPa+NsLy926AJ49LVfwVMJl1QaUKmkx31BY7B+yXQC > dECRbjUhC > certif:/yfkdU/vrUFdVzYroq2IRgQTEQIABgUCQLON8QAKCRDDi5owJBAttWu > UAJ9hpr+0 > certif:WQzC3TeQp/VaORSodKlmugCfdT0EfVw8KaDwKsjWcEXgVnmIKTOIRgQ > SEQIABgUC > certif:QLEVUAAKCRDSD9QFytUJxiHsAJ9GkrBkUgXmd7c5W5A9jsnHEUMRtwC > aApkOihPH > certif:txfTHI/wMMSXMiYvKV+IRgQSEQIABgUCQLEVeAAKCRD9/49Y5NtE8nv > uAKCAsDMz > certif:rfPtYi7d5VVBmL+7g9psSACfbtupqhrf0Ct1t5RodFcPn+HECvWIRgQ > TEQIABgUC > certif:QLN2lQAKCRBy67Gw/wrP8Z+EAJ9VU6Sb0DOZILlS1G3Bb9Klibwm7wC > fZhL0YxSx > certif:CJNzCW+4GetIsc2C36mJAJUDBRBAs8tCB00bXzlXVz0BAcgxBACNqzx > lv+8Smqcj > certif:Rssja0KfOA66GfxeeosBzy1Up+T0q3IZd6QGmS9NEZyb+q7vgPjMJp2 > 25b1uWLlC > certif:IV2naSAWwur2NPIJchRcEomla3YPsUUUiojO4LdKLw8g5KhYc94W3hc > I19A3t0Zy > certif:9vjV+a4QWIP3xWog2YZEnO8KtOI+YYhGBBMRAgAGBQJAsvhOAAoJEET > gf8JTVkw2 > certif:bJEAnAvFkvUYeEzL34tCWlsv8oxLLLtYAJ4xU2FKhakkTNEg+5VN0fg > YQhn8lYhG > certif:BBMRAgAGBQJAtN6tAAoJENmYwRNs2bKfy+sAn2nAz/v4zLRUQ+dJQAA > OEsvUTSuZ > certif:AJwP54ShjZfcRcRgHlG+PaOQB1Z7MohGBBMRAgAGBQJAtO2YAAoJEDY > epjBucjE2 > certif:AtAAn2gV5jLwQzGnrke+lwSKuA7V90RBAKCIVVtbuuhFyqSClJ+M9fT > 20S9874hG > certif:BBIRAgAGBQJAuPLoAAoJEDZ7LWDl2y7aB+QAn2cN//y6S0iGBefjF8s > ElVs3fqQi > certif:AJ9o5zhj6PrMa6zbcOYVBzewQFGbx4hGBBIRAgAGBQJBdZVZAAoJEFw > KzE31uuOj > certif:clYAn3PTpjpquP0QtIr7KgkHR4DGk3QiAKDHMSTfwAxoUIB2jjUTRHW > ubdQXbYhG > certif:BBMRAgAGBQJBdBitAAoJEJVSPpf2Z1A7aKMAoOiWKC5fdFM2a+IEs5u > rRQvn2ijp > certif:AKCY8QluTS90gQ+bDqTJ/UPfER6/5ohhBDARAgAhBQJCM6RXGh0gZGV > wcmVjYXRl > certif:ZCBlbWFpbCBhZGRyZXNzAAoJEGnuM9r42wvL/mIAoPNMNRFEAXbBAaG > Boz8ogLHo > certif:ofBEAKCFK5bY7A/2qNgLt/40IFKju4AHQYhcBBMRAgAcAhsDBAsHAwI > DFQIDAxYC > certif:AQIeAQIXgAUCQjOkGQAKCRBp7jPa+NsLy5CjAJ9jZipSfZwbrK2LR5j > BAAfbxIk2 > certif:iACgn6DhVh7AM1cui8FNRtz0VcHkE1m5AQ0EPyVlZBAEALcTRnYLNv7 > TZsG18uwv > certif:XHGC9zEiMJURYBiZnH/WdpcttSheQ7GcQ7l5jWlbcsjuzopxVIf3KEK > rXH+xarIP > certif:doNkXvopRNrEEtzjdJoKVhqQ33irOLPxGjKchZOYCsCbm57zY8hTVn6 > NZNuHgNeE > certif:iTo9j9q02c+Eze3kddRf1wU/AAQNA/wIRADHs8plJ7sQnvDlFJjL5oi > k1n5Ec6Dz > certif:LM2NWpthV3nBsSt63/VAabpRgj/xfdWBdtSsmVJu6M/gDbH+35QXhFW > pOi4E3Yw5 > certif:a68BL6KFkhIkxApJG0suOboXu8kTTE/Ml7aj47UuCf0DhJSEAiylZuL > psj23Okd1 > certif:mU1G72p/nYhGBBgRAgAGBQJAsQlSAAoJEGnuM9r42wvL0VoAnRMZRM2 > 6+w+/Xwhx > certif:9GwHVj9gJKA8AJ98fejPyQ82Hx7qqWJs/CskXFuNZg== > certif:=iCIJ > certif:-----END PGP PUBLIC KEY BLOCK----- > mnt-by: MNT01-RIPE > changed: matt.pounsett at cira.ca 20051101 > source: RIPE > > -----BEGIN PGP SIGNATURE----- > Version: GnuPG v1.4.1 (Darwin) > > iD8DBQFD8jrCae4z2vjbC8sRAoXJAJ9gp18VPBpi+AinH++qBpclCkngMQCgq/Z3 > nCAZ4zce5HLeqkf+3xPw/Pk= > =y/o0 > -----END PGP SIGNATURE----- > ------ End forwarded message ------ > > ------ End forwarded message ------ From joao.pereira at fccn.pt Thu Feb 16 18:17:48 2006 From: joao.pereira at fccn.pt (Joao Pereira) Date: Thu, 16 Feb 2006 17:17:48 +0000 Subject: [enum-wg] ENUM motivation Message-ID: <43F4B3BC.6020208@fccn.pt> Hello We are beginning the request phase to the 1.5.3.e164.arpa in Portugal and we still have some doubts about the main motivation towards this technology, that would be from: - Traditional Telcos ? No, they want to bill all calls.... - New Telcos ? No, they want to keep their VoIP networks closed... - IP Telephony integrators (Alcatel, Cisco, Siemens,...)? Maybe... but they usually work together with the Telcos - the end users ? Yes :) Is this user interest going to be enough? And are they willing to pay for this registration? They can use free ENUM trees.... How can we push for more ENUM registrations in the e164.arpa tree? Thanks Joao Pereira FCCN From richard at shockey.us Thu Feb 16 18:32:25 2006 From: richard at shockey.us (Richard Shockey) Date: Thu, 16 Feb 2006 12:32:25 -0500 Subject: [enum-wg] ENUM motivation In-Reply-To: <43F4B3BC.6020208@fccn.pt> References: <43F4B3BC.6020208@fccn.pt> Message-ID: <43F4B729.2030606@shockey.us> Joao Pereira wrote: > Hello > We are beginning the request phase to the 1.5.3.e164.arpa in Portugal > and we still have some doubts about the main motivation towards this > technology, that would be from: > > - Traditional Telcos ? No, they want to bill all calls.... Correct incumbent teleco carriers do not like ENUM for the obvious reasons that is not unique to Portugal :-) > - New Telcos ? No, they want to keep their VoIP networks closed... Ah not really New Telecos especially Cable operators entering the VoIP space want to avoid paying termination and compensation to the incumbent for calls. They wish to engage in IP to IP end to end calling and a "bill and keep" economic model of interconnection. Consequently have a very serious rationale for using ENUM in some form Public, Private or Infrastructure. That is certainly the emerging model in the US and in the EC. We're seening lots of activity on that front in US CA NL AT etc. > - IP Telephony integrators (Alcatel, Cisco, Siemens,...)? Maybe... but > they usually work together with the Telcos Think about interconnecting enterprise PBX's. > - the end users ? Yes :) > > Is this user interest going to be enough? Early results from Austria and the EC indicate its a long adoption cycle yes. > And are they willing to pay for this registration? They can use free > ENUM trees.... It depends on how much you charge. Free trees are not e164.apra we have designed the namespace to maximize its authority and integrity. But you cant charge too much for registrations. > How can we push for more ENUM registrations in the e164.arpa tree? Well part of the problem is the scale of the tree and the US and Canada have been part of that problem. The EC countries have been way ahead of us in North America on the adoption curve but now that 1.e164.arpa will come on line soon and Japan and Korea etc there is reason to believe some critical mass will begin to accelerate adoption. > > Thanks > Joao Pereira > FCCN > > -- >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Richard Shockey, Director - Member of Technical Staff NeuStar Inc. 46000 Center Oak Plaza - Sterling, VA 20166 sip:rshockey(at)iptel.org sip:57141(at)fwd.pulver.com ENUM +87810-13313-31331 PSTN Office +1 571.434.5651 PSTN Mobile +1 703.593.2683 Fax: +1 815.333.1237 or ; <<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< From ronan.lupton at ie.verizonbusiness.com Thu Feb 16 18:27:35 2006 From: ronan.lupton at ie.verizonbusiness.com (Lupton, Ronan) Date: Thu, 16 Feb 2006 17:27:35 -0000 Subject: [enum-wg] ENUM motivation Message-ID: Joao, There was a conference in Lisbon in November last discussing the various aspects of the ENUM play/s motivation etc. A number of people were in attendance from Telecom Portugal, I would be happy to discuss these contact with you bilaterally. Perhaps the forum is not the best place to ask these questions, but there are certainly folks who have interesting views. My own view is that this standard radically simplifies some of the more complex PSTN addressing problems and multiplicity of addressing issues consumers face. The markets are going to have to decide to a large extent how this standard develops. You may have noticed that the NANP, country code 1 (USA) delegation was approved yesterday. That might bring even more momentum to adoption of the standard. Regards, Ronan Ronan Lupton Senior Regulatory Manager & EMEA Interconnect Policy International Affairs Verizon Business Lower Erne St. Dublin 2. Ireland Tel: +353-1-2474525 Fax: +353-1-2474545 ENUM: +35315069888 mailto:ronan.lupton at ie.verizonbusiness.com Verizon and MCI are now operating as Verizon Business -----Original Message----- From: enum-wg-admin at ripe.net [mailto:enum-wg-admin at ripe.net] On Behalf Of Joao Pereira Sent: 16 February 2006 17:18 To: enum-wg at ripe.net Subject: [enum-wg] ENUM motivation Hello We are beginning the request phase to the 1.5.3.e164.arpa in Portugal and we still have some doubts about the main motivation towards this technology, that would be from: - Traditional Telcos ? No, they want to bill all calls.... - New Telcos ? No, they want to keep their VoIP networks closed... - IP Telephony integrators (Alcatel, Cisco, Siemens,...)? Maybe... but they usually work together with the Telcos - the end users ? Yes :) Is this user interest going to be enough? And are they willing to pay for this registration? They can use free ENUM trees.... How can we push for more ENUM registrations in the e164.arpa tree? Thanks Joao Pereira FCCN -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From enumvoipsip.cs at schiefner.de Mon Feb 20 16:55:48 2006 From: enumvoipsip.cs at schiefner.de (Carsten Schiefner) Date: Mon, 20 Feb 2006 16:55:48 +0100 Subject: [enum-wg] Delegation of +1/1.e164.arpa (almost) completed In-Reply-To: <43F335CD.2040106@schiefner.de> References: <43F335CD.2040106@schiefner.de> Message-ID: <43F9E684.70106@schiefner.de> Dear colleagues, more information on the US ENUM trial is available at: http://ustrial.enumllc.com/ Regards, Carsten Schiefner Carsten Schiefner wrote: > Dear colleagues, > > the ENUM delegation request for 1.e164.arpa - +1 is the E.164 CC for the > North American Numbering Plan (NANP) - has just been confirmed by ITU-T > TSB. > > I expect the technical delegation to be just a matter of time then. > > Furthermore, given the size of possible delegations under 1.e164.arpa, I > consider this a major step forward for Public User ENUM. > > Congratulations to all who worked on the ENUM LLC and on the project in > general over the last couple of years. > > Best, > > Carsten Schiefner From enumvoipsip.cs at schiefner.de Tue Feb 21 16:02:28 2006 From: enumvoipsip.cs at schiefner.de (Carsten Schiefner) Date: Tue, 21 Feb 2006 16:02:28 +0100 Subject: [enum-wg] Delegation of +1/1.e164.arpa (almost) completed In-Reply-To: <43F335CD.2040106@schiefner.de> References: <43F335CD.2040106@schiefner.de> Message-ID: <43FB2B84.7020204@schiefner.de> Dear colleagues, Carsten Schiefner wrote: > the ENUM delegation request for 1.e164.arpa - +1 is the E.164 CC for the > North American Numbering Plan (NANP) - has just been confirmed by ITU-T > TSB. > > I expect the technical delegation to be just a matter of time then. as per yesterday, 1.e164.arpa is delegated to ns01.enum-1a.ca. [192.228.22.70] ns02.enum-1a.ca. [192.228.22.71] Best, Carsten Schiefner